DB-SI in a dwelling refurbishment: what to justify and what not
In a refurbishment DB-SI neither applies in full nor stops applying. It reaches what the work alters, escape routes if occupancy changes and protection systems if what carries them is touched. Existing safety can never be made worse.

In this article
The short version
This justification is sometimes dismissed with «not applicable». That can leave the reviewer with doubts, because in a refurbishment DB-SI applies in part. We follow the Basic Document SI (fire safety) in its version of 4 March 2025, the Ministry’s annotated edition of the same date and article 2 of Part I of the code. The rules are Spanish. The logic of proportionate upgrading will be familiar to anyone who has worked on existing buildings elsewhere.
First: maintenance, refurbishment or change of use
Annex III of Part I defines the interventions in existing buildings: extension, refurbishment and change of use. Refurbishment is any work on an existing building other than that carried out solely for its maintenance. Maintenance is the periodic work to prevent deterioration or the one-off repairs that keep the building in good order. The Ministry’s comment puts it plainly: maintenance work does not have to apply the building code.
The same comment gives a useful example: taking down suspended ceilings to repair the infill blocks of a floor and putting them back is maintenance and can be limited to its purpose. Changing the layout, rebuilding bathrooms and kitchen or renewing a dwelling’s services is refurbishment. For refurbishment, article 2.3 of Part I requires the code to be justified in a project or in a report signed by a qualified professional. Where the procedure is a declaration of compliance, the applicant must state that such a project or report exists.
DB-SI’s three rules for refurbishment
The introduction to DB-SI (section III) sets out how it applies to refurbishments that keep the use. There are three rules and the justification should go through them one by one:
| Rule | What it says | What it means for a dwelling |
|---|---|---|
| 9. Altered elements | The document applies to the elements the work alters, provided that brings them closer to it. | Whatever is rebuilt is rebuilt to the document: a wall shared with another dwelling, a floor slab, a service penetration. |
| 10. Escape and installations | If occupancy or its distribution relative to the means of escape changes, the document reaches those too. If the supports of fire protection installations are affected, the installations are upgraded. | An internal refurbishment seldom changes the building’s means of escape. Splitting one dwelling into two or joining two may. |
| 11. No worsening | The work cannot reduce existing safety conditions where they fall short of the document. | No unprotected opening in a wall that currently separates and no unsealed penetration that did not exist before. |
The Ministry’s comment adds the key to reading them: no intervention is expected to bring the whole building up to the document, which «in many cases would be impossible». What is expected is proportion between the scope of the work and the safety improvement. Where the document cannot be met, article 2.3 of Part I allows the greatest possible degree of effective compliance. The project justifies it and the as-built documentation records the level reached.
What DB-SI does not ask inside the dwelling
Many of the requirements stop at the dwelling’s front door. It is worth saying so in the report with the clause, rather than a bare «not applicable»:
- Escape routes. Annex SI A excludes points inside dwellings from the origin of evacuation. The route lengths in SI 3 table 3.1 are measured in the common areas, from each dwelling’s door.
- Reaction to fire of linings. SI 1 table 4.1 asks for C-s2,d0 on walls and ceilings and EFL on floors in occupiable areas. Its note 4 excludes the inside of dwellings. The row for concealed spaces (suspended ceilings, raised floors) exempts those inside them.
- Fire protection installations. For residential use, SI 4 table 1.1 asks for a dry riser above 24 m of evacuation height, detection and alarm above 50 m and hydrants from 5,000 m² of floor area. Extinguishers go within 15 m of every origin of evacuation, that is, in the common areas. An internal refurbishment does not trigger them.
- Occupancy. The design density for dwelling floors is 20 m² per person (SI 3 table 2.1). It only matters if the work changes the number of dwellings or how they relate to the stair.
If the work reaches the stair or the entrance hall, those are common areas and all of the above applies.
What does apply when the work touches it
Where a dwelling refurbishment usually has something real to justify is at its edges: what separates it from other dwellings, from the common areas and from the building next door.
| Element | Requirement | Clause |
|---|---|---|
| Walls and floors between dwellings | At least EI 60 | SI 1, table 1.1 |
| Service penetrations through them | Keep their resistance with fire stopping or EI t through-elements. Penetrations up to 50 cm² are excluded | SI 1, section 3 |
| Continuity in concealed spaces | Compartmentation carries on through shafts, cavities, suspended ceilings and raised floors | SI 1, section 3 |
| Party wall with another building | At least EI 120 | SI 2, section 1 |
| Structure being altered | For residential buildings, R 60 above ground up to 15 m of evacuation height and R 120 in basements. For a single-family house, R 30 | SI 6, table 3.1 |
| Façade systems, if the façade is rebuilt | Reaction to fire D-s3,d0 up to 10 m high, C-s3,d0 up to 18 m and B-s3,d0 above, where they cover more than 10% of the surface | SI 2, section 1 |
| Storage room over 50 m² in the building | Special-risk room, low, medium or high depending on its area | SI 1, table 2.1 |
Two details that are easy to miss. In terraced or semi-detached houses, the elements of the shared structure must have the resistance required for residential buildings, not for a single-family house (note 2 to SI 6 table 3.1). And article 2.4 of Part I requires the project to state whether the work touches the existing structure or not. Everything else is read in the light of that sentence.
Change of use and listed buildings
If a shop becomes a dwelling, it is no longer a refurbishment that keeps the use. Rule 8 of the introduction applies the document to the part that changes and to the means of escape serving it up to a safe external space. There is one express exception: where an area of another use is turned into a dwelling inside an existing residential building, the document need not be applied to the common means of escape. We cover the rest of a change of use in retail to residential change of use.
In a listed building, where the document is incompatible with its protection grade, alternative solutions may be used that allow the greatest technical and economic degree of compliance. The as-built documentation must record any limits on use arising from the level reached (section III of the introduction). The alternative has to be described and justified: the listing explains why the document is not met but does not replace the justification.
What to write in the report
In a dwelling refurbishment, the DB-SI justification usually fits on half a page. What should be written down:
- The type of intervention under annex III of Part I and whether it touches the structure (article 2.4).
- The building’s use, evacuation height and whether the dwelling is a house or part of a block of flats.
- Which elements the work alters and how they meet the document: EI 60 separations, EI 120 party wall, structure with its R.
- Whether occupancy or its relation to the stair changes and why the building’s means of escape are unaffected.
- Whether the supports of the building’s fire protection installations are affected and what is done about them.
- How service penetrations through compartment elements are solved: sealant, intumescent collar or EI duct.
- The statement that existing safety conditions are not reduced.
- If the document is not met, the solution adopted, why it was adopted and the level of performance that remains.
Common mistakes
- Writing «not applicable, as this is a refurbishment»: the document does apply, through rules 9, 10 and 11.
- Asking for C-s2,d0 linings inside the dwelling or justifying escape routes within it.
- Replacing a wall shared with another dwelling with a plasterboard system without stating its EI.
- Running new extract ducts or soil stacks through floors without saying how the penetration is sealed.
- A report saying the structure is untouched and drawings showing an opening in a load-bearing wall. We discuss cross-checking report, drawings and estimate in what a project report must contain.
How Archelo handles it
Archelo shows in its regulations view the DB-SI figures for the project’s use, each with its table: design occupancy, exits, route lengths and widths. It also checks whether the report justifies DB-SI and whether what it says matches the drawings and the estimate. It does not decide whether a job is maintenance or refurbishment, nor certify the fire resistance of a build-up: that is the designer’s judgement. What it points out is where it still needs writing down.
You can see how it works on AI for architects. This article is for information and does not replace checking the code’s text in force, the local bylaws or any heritage rules that apply to the building.
















